Is long time no see really from Chinese?
Maybe. Sources agree that the phrase came from pidgin English, a simple, mixed form of English, and that it first appeared in the United States in the late 1800s. What is still open is whose pidgin English it was.
- The Chinese idea. Word for word, 好久不见 is close to “very long not see.” 好久 hǎojiǔ is literally “good long” and means a long time, 不 means “not,” and 见 jiàn means “see” or “meet” [3]. The earliest example found so far is a short story, “Lee Hing’s Girl,” printed in the Seattle Post-Intelligencer in 1892. Its writer twice calls the phrase “pigeon English,” an old name for Chinese Pidgin English [3].
- The Native American idea. The Oxford English Dictionary’s earliest quote is from the Boston Daily Globe in 1894, where a writer imitates Native American speech. Word Histories argues that the dictionary is wrong to point to a Native American origin [3]. NPR also notes two Westerns from 1900 where Native American characters say the line, and treats both ideas as possible [2].
So the best answer today is this. The phrase appeared in American English in the 1890s, and the earliest finds lean slightly toward Chinese Pidgin English. The word-for-word link to 好久不见 is a good guess, but it is not proven.
| Point | English long time no see | Chinese 好久不见 |
|---|---|---|
| Grammar | Does not follow normal grammar; works as a fixed phrase | Normal, correct Chinese |
| Feeling | Casual, friendly, a little playful | Neutral and warm |
| Who you say it to | Friends, coworkers, people you know well | Almost anyone you have met before |
| Other forms | “long time, no see,” LTNS | 好久没见 hǎojiǔ méi jiàn, 很久没见 hěnjiǔ méi jiàn, the more formal 久违了 jiǔwéi le, Cantonese 好耐冇見 hou2 noi6 mou5 gin3 |
Is it rude? In Chinese, no: 好久不见 is a standard greeting, and teachers show it to beginners. In English, some inclusive-language guides, including a few from US universities, have listed it as a phrase to avoid, because it may have started as a way of copying how non-native speakers talked. Many people disagree, and most speakers use it without a second thought. If you would rather skip the question, “it’s been a while” says the same thing.
Sources
- LONG TIME NO SEE definitionCambridge Dictionary
- Who First Said 'Long Time, No See' And In Which Language?NPR Code Switch, March 9, 2014
- Pidgin-English origin of 'long time no see'Word Histories (Pascal Tréguer), January 21, 2018