Xianxia vs. wuxia vs. xuanhuan
Fans of Chinese fantasy use three genre words a lot, and they overlap. Here is the rough difference.
| Genre | Chinese | What the heroes want | How much magic |
|---|---|---|---|
| Wuxia | 武侠 wǔxiá, “martial heroes” | Justice, honor, revenge, skill with a sword | Little or none |
| Xianxia | 仙侠 xiānxiá, “immortal heroes” | Power and eternal life through cultivation | A lot: flying swords, demons, immortals |
| Xuanhuan | 玄幻 xuánhuàn, “mysterious fantasy” | Power, often in a made-up world | A lot, and it can mix in anything |
Xianxia stays close to Chinese myth and religion. Wikipedia describes it as influenced by Taoism and Chan Buddhism [2]. Xuanhuan is freer: its worlds can borrow from Western fantasy, games, or nowhere at all.
In English, fans often use xianxia loosely for any cultivation story, where a hero trains their energy (qi) to climb through levels of power. Many of those stories are filed as xuanhuan on Chinese sites. So the English word covers more ground than the Chinese one.
Chinese critics admit the lines are blurry too. A 2015 article on China Writers Net calls xuanhuan and xianxia two major categories of online writing, but says the line between them is “not clear-cut, even blurry” [3]. The same article says that, strictly speaking, xianxia is a story form of traditional wuxia fiction that adds the “immortal” element to the hero tradition [3]. Huanzhulouzhu’s novel Legend of the Swordsmen of the Mountains of Shu (蜀山剑侠传 Shǔshān jiànxiá zhuàn), first published from 1932, is widely seen as the first true xianxia novel [2].
Sources
- General Glossary of Terms (Glossary of Terms in Wuxia, Xianxia & Xuanhuan Novels)Wuxiaworld
- XianxiaWikipedia
- 关于玄幻与仙侠小说中国作家网 (China Writers Net), May 26, 2015